Dear David Shore, WHY!?!?!?!
April 29th, 2006 at 10:23 pm, 4 years agoSo, I just got done watching the opening pilot episode of the first episode of House.
First off, something nice, your writing talent was well received in the first episode. Your writing is what makes your works so likable.
It was perhaps the defining moment of the show, and by far the most beautiful. Then, Mr. Shore, the show that you probably worked hard to get the funding for a pilot for this “new idea,” and somehow the second episode becomes the least artistic and most “user friendly” piece I have seen. First off, you change the opening logo to some crappy song that tries “embrace the emotion of the show” or whatever. Forget that the pilot had no music, but introduced you to the characters in a much more dramatic way that advances the story. I don’t remember the place that made the intro (I was at their website once) but somebody went to some intro creating place that attempts to make the intro more enticing than the actual show. THEN during the second episode, you use some song that is totally inappropriate and serves no purpose other than to bias the watcher into thinking this is some insane dangerous spur of the moment drama. That may be it, but you have the same amount of time as the pilot as you do for your second show. It isn’t like you can’t go slow.
But here is what really gets me: YOU REMOVED THE ‘WARM’ FILTER YOU USED ON THE PILOT. The pilot had a flair of artistic intent, very much created by a filter you either used in your camera or during post. So what happens in the second episode? You cold start into a the brightest, greenest, football field that you can find! And there is NO FILTER. WHAT THE FUCK? The writing for the first episode was perfect, obviously when the creator of the series writes a show it has special meaning, but obviously you have oversight and have to approve everything before it is shot.
All I can say here is that after Fox picked this show up some idiot had a ‘focus group’ of ‘ordinary Americans’ and they thought that it could use xyz. If it was a focus group, why the hell did you let them fuck the show so much?
Do you even care about what you created? ER had a great first season because there was consistent drama and the characters were consistent. People LIKED ER. It took seaons for that style to change for the worse, you managed to do it in ONE FUCKING EPISODE.
BUT THEN you do something REALLY INTERSTING, you team up with Bryan Singer (Director of Pilot, X-Men Series, etc) on the 3rd episode and all of a sudden things change and make it a little (not a lot) better. Why is it better, you didn’t add so many bright colors and ferns everywhere. The actors still seem too fucking happy and way too independent than they were during the first episode. Why aren’t they more afraid of house, more inquisitive, etc. All of a sudden they become much more liberal and independent. Is this the same show?
ARUG! I’m going to sit back and pray that you, Singer, and tell the DP you used on the pilot to go back and do a show that seem much better directed and edgy instead of a nighttime drama that is going to last 4 seasons and be forgotten by everyone. Until then, I’ll keep watching, and I’ll forget about how good the pilot was. Then wait until you do another pilot and have the show destroyed during the 2nd episode.

